In a clear signal that regulatory scrutiny over off-channel communications remains at an all-time high, the SEC and CFTC have levied significant penalties against numerous financial firms, dispelling any lingering notions of a softening stance.
These enforcement actions, totaling close to $400 million in combined penalties, underscore the regulators’ ongoing commitment to strict enforcement of communications compliance and reflect an expanding focus beyond tier-one banks to include a broader array of investment advisers and broker-dealers.
SEC’s Sweeping Enforcement Action
On August 14, 2024, the SEC announced a monumental enforcement action against 26 broker-dealers and investment advisers for widespread and longstanding failures to maintain and preserve electronic communications. The penalties, which collectively amount to $393 million, are part of a larger regulatory crackdown aimed at ensuring compliance with the federal securities laws’ books and records provisions.
The firms involved have admitted to the SEC’s findings. The findings reveal the pervasive use of unapproved communication methods, often referred to as "off-channel communications," by personnel at multiple levels, including senior management. The SEC emphasized that these record keeping failures compromised its ability to conduct effective investigations, thus posing significant risks to investor protection and market integrity.
Gurbir S. Grewal, Director of the SEC’s Division of Enforcement, highlighted the seriousness of these breaches, stating, “As today’s enforcement actions against more than two dozen firms reflect, we remain committed to ensuring compliance with the books and records requirements of the federal securities laws, which are essential to investor protection and well-functioning markets.”
The substantial penalties imposed and the requirement for firms to cease and desist from future violations make it clear that the SEC’s enforcement strategy is far from lenient.
CFTC’s Reinforced Message with $3 million fine
On the same day, the CFTC reinforced its unwavering stance on record keeping violations with an order against a swap dealer, for similar failures in maintaining required records and supervising its communications protocols. While the $3 million penalty is more modest than the SEC fines, it reflects the CFTC’s recognition of the Swap Dealer’s proactive approach to self-reporting its violations.
The case is particularly noteworthy because it highlights the benefits of self-reporting and cooperation with regulators. The bank’s decision to conduct an internal review and promptly disclose its widespread use of unapproved communication methods by employees—including senior-level staff—resulted in a substantially reduced penalty.
This outcome underscores the CFTC’s message that while the agency remains vigilant, there is a tangible incentive for firms that choose to self-report and remediate their compliance failures.
Ian McGinley, Director of the CFTC’s Division of Enforcement, remarked, “[The firm’s] decision to self-report, cooperate, remediate, and be held accountable allowed it to benefit in the form of a substantially reduced penalty. At the same time, the CFTC’s message remains clear—record keeping and supervision requirements are fundamental, and registrants that fail to comply with these core obligations do so at their own peril.”
No Softening in Regulatory Enforcement
The combined actions by the SEC and CFTC send a powerful message: the crackdown on off-channel communications breaches is not only ongoing but also expanding in scope. By targeting a broader range of financial firms, including investment advisers and broker-dealers, regulators are making it unequivocally clear that no firm is beyond their reach.
These enforcement actions also dispel any speculation that the regulatory environment might become more lenient. On the contrary, the SEC and CFTC are doubling down on their efforts to enforce compliance with record keeping requirements, a cornerstone of effective market oversight. Firms are thus reminded of the critical importance of maintaining robust compliance systems and the severe consequences of failing to do so.
As the regulatory landscape continues to evolve, financial institutions must remain vigilant, ensuring that all business-related communications, whether on approved channels or otherwise, are properly monitored and preserved. The risks of non-compliance have never been higher, and these recent penalties are a stark reminder of the serious financial and reputational damage that can result from inadequate oversight.
Enhance your Communications Compliance with SteelEye
SteelEye offers a comprehensive, user-friendly communications compliance platform designed to enhance and streamline record keeping and surveillance for financial firms.
The platform captures and secures communications data from a wide range of eComms, vComms, and traditional channels, storing them in a compliant, immutable format that meets regulatory standards. But we don't stop there. SteelEye leverages advanced surveillance algorithms, AI, and intelligent lexicon searches to detect early signs of misconduct and market abuse.
Moreover, SteelEye's proactive monitoring capabilities can identify and flag attempts to switch to unauthorized communication channels, helping you stay ahead of potential risks and ensure regulatory compliance.
Discover the complete Communications Oversight solution here >
